6 Best Crib Mattresses of 2019

Buying a crib for your newborn also means buying a mattress, since most either come with a very thin mattress or no mattress at all, but how to find the best crib mattress?

The mattress you choose for your baby is pretty important, considering that newborns sleep an average of 16 hours each day. Just as there are different types of mattresses for adults, there are now different types for infants and toddlers. Here you will learn which is the best crib mattress in each category.

6. Simmons Kids Beautyrest 2 Stage Dual Sided Crib And Toddler Mattress

This Simmons mattress certainly earns a spot in the running for the best crib mattresses. While most crib mattresses will fit a toddler bed, this one has two different sides designed in two different ways. Therefore, it can provide comfort for your child during both the infant and toddler stage.

The mattress has springs  for extra support for your infant, and an added layer of gel memory foam for extra comfort for your toddler. The mattress also has a foam encasement and Argentum+ woven cover that parents love because it is cooling to the child. This dual-sided mattress is GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR-US certified. It comes with a lifetime warranty and will fit into a standard sized crib.

Yass

• Long-lasting mattress with a toddler side and an infant side
• Comfortable and easy to clean

Nope

• Not 100% waterproof

5. Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Crib Mattress

Kolcraft offers what many parents consider the best crib mattress with inner springs. This mattress, packed with heavy gauge steel coils, provides the support that your baby or toddler needs. While it is not considered to be fully organic, it is still GREENGUARD Gold certified due to its low chemical emissions. The non-allergenic Perma-Dri cover is waterproof and easily wipes clean. Parents love how easy this mattress makes clean ups while potty training. The 51.63″ x 27.25″ x 5″ mattress will fit cribs and toddler beds.

Yass

• Comes with a reinforced waterproof cover
• All materials are Greenguard Gold certified

Nope

• Less firm than other infant mattresses

Recommended read:  The best toddler pillows and some great-rated baby cribs available for purchase at the moment!

4. My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress

Many new parents rave about this memory foam mattress manufactured by My First Mattress as being the best crib mattress around. Why? Because not only is it very soft and comfortable, but it also has a waterproof cover that is made of soft and plush fabric instead of a noisy plastic material. Measuring in at 51-5/8″ x 27-1/4″ x 5″ this mattress will fit any standard crib. The polyurethane foam is hypoallergenic and provides the support that your baby’s fragile skeletal system needs.

The biggest complaint that parents have is that when you first open the package there is a strong smell, similar to that of a new car. However, this is true of most memory foam mattresses. Simply give the mattress some time to air out, as well as to fill out the crib as there will be some initial shrinkage from packaging.

Yass

• Firm and lightweight mattress
• Comes with a very soft and comfy cover

Nopes

• A bit short for a standard crib
• Thinner than the standard, which means sheets will not fit tightly

3. Milliard Hypoallergenic Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress

This Milliard crib and toddler bed mattress is made of soft, high-quality foam that will not flatten over time. It’s completely chemical-free and safe – it also has a certification for preventing SIDS as it doesn’t allow the baby to sink into the mattress. In addition, this mattress comes with a hypoallergenic and 100% waterproof mattress cover that can be cleaned simply by wiping it.

Yass

• Firm, safe mattress for babies and toddlers that keeps its shape with time
• The waterproof cover is very convenient

Nope

• Comes with a chemical smell that requires about a week to go away

2. Sealy Soybean Serenity Foam-Core Crib Mattress

Sealy’s Soybean Mattress is the best crib mattress of the organic type. This 52″ x 28″ x 5″ mattress has a lightweight foam-core that is made from high-density soybean. This mattress is CertiPur-US certified and comes with a GREENGUARD certified organic cotton fabric cover that is waterproof, eco-friendly, and hypoallergenic. While it is one of the safest mattresses on the market, being made from natural materials, it still provides firmness and comfort for your precious child.

Yass

• Comes with a lifetime guarantee
• Has a waterproof surface that protects against allergens and stains
• Greenguard Gold certified
• Completely free of phthalates, lead, formaldehyde, or flame retardants

Nope

• Even though its cover contains organic fibers, the mattress is not organic

1. Newton Baby Wovenaire Fully Breathable Crib Mattress

Newton Baby now sells a latex mattress that is the best crib mattress in its category. This mattress takes the term “breathability” to a whole new level. The mattress is 90% air and 10% food-grade polymer, which means it is 100% recyclable. Many parents claim that they have tested the mattress by putting their face in it and breathing, and it actually worked!

With this mattress, you can rest a bit easier knowing that your baby will not be in harm’s way if they roll over in the middle of the night as one of the main causes of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) is accidental suffocation from sleeping on the stomach or side. What’s more, this woven airy crib mattress only weighs 11 pounds, making it easy to change the sheets. Both the mattress cover and the mattress itself are washable, making it easy to clean up any accidents that your baby may have while asleep.

Yass

• Completely washable
• Made of safe materials

Nope

• Pricier than others on our list

Conclusion

Oftentimes even newborns have preferences. So, parents have to try out a few different mattresses before they find one that their baby can sleep soundly on. When shopping for the best crib mattress for your child, it is important to remember that a firm mattress is a good thing for infants, as it provides the support that their fragile bones need as they begin to grow.

Most crib manufacturers are aware of this aspect and design their mattresses accordingly, so that’s one less thing you need to fret over while shopping. Perhaps your child requires a hypoallergenic mattress. Or maybe you sleep easier at night knowing that your newborn is resting on a fully breathable mattress. Whatever expectations you and your child may have from a crib mattress, rest assured that the perfect mattress for them is just one click away.

Editor’s note: this post was first uploaded in April 2017 and has received multiple updates, including the most recent one in August 2019.